Contemporary case in South Africa deals with a worker fired for a WhatsApp message – right here’s what it’s most practical to composed know


With South African businesses and staff increasing an increasing selection of reliant on WhatsApp as a approach of verbal change, it has develop into an increasing selection of overall for labour disputes to come up around the messaging platform.

In relation to our labour law, any dismissal of an worker desires to be exquisite and objective proper in terms of the Labour Relations Act. So, if an worker is to be disregarded for a WhatsApp message, this dismissal ought to meet the necessities of the Act, says proper kind firm Wright Rose Innes.

The firm pointed to the sizzling CCMA case of Masondo/AG Electrical (Pty) Ltd [2022] 4 BALR 400 (CCMA) the assign an worker used to be disregarded after he had sent a WhatsApp message threatening to waste his employer as well to an legit of the bargaining council, presently after the employer had positioned its staff on short working time in the future of the Covid-19 pandemic.

“Two contradictory views were positioned outdated to the Commissioner. The employer perceived the WhatsApp message as an intentional possibility of bodily violence, whereas, the worker indicated that he used to be merely making an try to lend a hand his fellow co-workers who confronted a same wretchedness as he did.

“The employer’s model used to be no longer disputed by the worker and nor did he non-public any remorse or present sound causes for the message which he had sent.”

The final result used to be that the CCMA held that the worker’s conduct used to be viewed to non-public broken down the employer-worker relationship and his dismissal used to be thus confirmed to be substantively and procedurally exquisite, the firm acknowledged.

“In this kind, the CCMA confirmed that a WhatsApp message can fresh grounds for dismissal, but as persistently, the facts of every case will desire to be judicious to resolve whether there are grounds for dismissal or no longer.”

WhatsApp groups

In August 2020, Discovery Neatly being disregarded 10 staff for contravening the corporate’s social media policy and acting maliciously towards the corporate, in step with the messages in a WhatsApp community.

The staff started the community to toughen every different after contracting Covid-19 in April.

The staff complained to the Commission for Conciliation, Mediation, and Arbitration (CCMA) about their dismissal, arguing that they were unfairly disregarded and aggravating 12 months’ salary from the corporate as compensation. They accused the corporate of unhealthy labour practices and invading their privacy.

Discovery Neatly being chief executive Ryan Noach advised the Sunday Instances that a whistleblower who used to be a member of the WhatsApp community reported the females and made accessible the contents of their discussions.

These discussions “printed obvious and explicit particulars of these staff … initiating, planning and coordinating efforts to maliciously shut down Discovery,” he acknowledged.

In its letter to indubitably one of the affected workers, Discovery Neatly being acknowledged the worker had “shared info and messages that were clearly prejudicial to and derogatory of the corporate” and accused them of making unfaithful and harmful statements about the corporate to an external bag together and attempting to organise a shutdown of Discovery locations of work in Port Elizabeth and Cape City.

“Our expectations are that staff broaden concerns internally, affording us the different to justify or resolve any items that can present enlighten off to without reference to concerns they’ll also objective non-public,” Noach acknowledged.

“The evidence that we’ve in our possession illustrates that this community failed to absorb opportunities to pick particular concerns internally and as an different selected to act maliciously and unfairly in an strive to create their awful halt of an pickle of business closure by bringing the corporate into disrepute.”

Be taught: Meta engaged on different devices for the wrist


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Share post:



More like this

EU has no basis for cold storage requirements on SA citrus exports – farmers

EU has no basis for cold storage requirements on SA citrus exports - farmers The European Union is demanding that citrus exports from South Africa be subjected to extreme cold storage in a bid to stave off false codling moth infestation. @ proler/ Citrus exports World Trade Organization SA citrus farmers False codling moth Cold

Eskom submits tariff restructuring application to Nersa

Eskom submits tariff restructuring application to Nersa At this stage, the utility has not indicated how much tariffs could be raised. The new tariffs will come into effect in April. Eskom's Megawatt Park head office in Sunninghill, Johannesburg. Picture: Xanderleigh Dookey Makhaza/Eyewitness News National Energy Regulator of South Africa Eskom tariffs Email Print Tweet Share

Unions: Eskom must improve 3 issues for wage talks to move forward

Unions: Eskom must improve 3 issues for wage talks to move forward Negotiations between the power utility and unions resumed on Friday morning after reaching a dead-end last week. Eskom Megawatt Park. Picture Xanderleigh Dookey-Makhaza/Eyewitness News. Eskom Load shedding NUMSA Wage strike Email Print Tweet Share Theto Mahlakoana | 40 days ago JOHANNESBURG - Trade unions at

City of Cape Town drafts new policy for mobile businesses

City of Cape Town drafts new policy for mobile businesses It drafted a Mobile Business Policy, which aims to support this growing sector by putting measures in place that would make it easier to apply and operate. FILE: Economic Growth Mayor James Vos said the city welcomed innovative ways of doing business that stimulated the